Showing posts with label sexism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sexism. Show all posts
2 com

Stephen Leacock's Last Laugh

I couldn't believe my eyes this morning when I read about the CBC's "disappointment" that the Stephen Leacock Association had announced an all-male shortlist for the 2011 Stephen Leacock Medal for Humour. It expressed its dismay and then went on to name 10 "rich, hilarious" Canadian women writers.

That's quite an about-face for our publicly funded radio and television network, which just two months ago bestowed the 2011 Canada Reads and best book of the decade award on a self-published male novelist, the 8th male writer in its 10 year history. Among calls of sexism in the publishing world, the CBC's Michael Enright looked into sexist practices at major literary publications a few weeks later. Enright's question--why are there so few women with bylines at major literary publications? And there were some funny reasons. But progress is progress, right?

Anyway, I decided to do a little bit of research into the Stephen Leacock Medal for Humour, and once again, I was astounded. In the 63 years that the Stephen Leacock Association has been awarding medals for humour, only five recipients have been women, or one shy of the number of male winners with the surname Ferguson. Hilarious! Unfortunately, the Stephen Leacock Award was fair in the beginning with three women winners in the first eight years. Then the next female winner wasn't until 1979. The winner of the Stephen Leacock medal receives $15,000, while the other short-listed writers receive "a cheque." But it's not really about the money, is it?

The Stephen Leacock Award for Humour still carries a lot of weight in the eyes of the Canadian public, and it can be said that Terry Fallis's 2011 Canada Reads nomination for the Best Laid Plans had a lot to do with his Stephen Leacock Medal in 2008. After all, it was given the label "the funniest," which like "the best" and "most important," are completely subjective terms that nevertheless go a long way in selling books.

But how many women would even submit their book when the last woman winner was in 1996? Or the fact that only five women writers have been shortlisted since 2002? (Sorry, I couldn't find any data farther back than that.) It brings us back to the same line of questioning that Michael Enright raised with his panelists: why are there so few women writers with bylines at major literary publications? The reason the panelists gave was because men tried harder and resubmitted their work after they were rejected. Ergo women are quitters? No, women are smart enough to realize that when they see one woman's name among 10 men with bylines that they're better off putting their energy elsewhere. Ditto for women writers looking at a winner's list with 63 names and seeing only five that belong to women. There you have it: sexism in black and white.

As we have seen, the Stephen Leacock Award can launch a literary career, so in the interest of fairness, shouldn't the Association be looking into its own practices? Or rather shouldn't its sponsors, the Ontario Trillium Foundation, funded by Ontario taxpayers, be pressuring the Stephen Leacock Association to make some much-needed changes. Calls of sexism also reflect poorly on the other sponsors: the TD Financial Group, the City of Orillia, Lakehead University, Osprey Media Group and Sun Media, not to mention Stephen Leacock himself.

Sexism is no laughing matter.

Here's the link to the podcast of Michael Enright's program: CBC.ca | The Sunday Edition | Women in Publishing - MMR Autism Scandal - Phil Ochs Documentary

Related posts
The CBC Investigates Sexism in Publishing
Guerrilla Girls, Humour and Hope
Publishing: What If...?
Publishing: What's "Good" and "Important"  (Stats on the # of books authored by women that are reviewed)
CBC: The Elephant in the Room  (Terry Fallis's book beats Carol Shields in CanadaReads)
Reads from Men


.
Read more »
2 com

The CBC Investigates Sexism in Publishing

Note Mirror At Top to Fix Hair Before Meal
First of all, Happy International Women's Day! As you may already know, we are celebrating this glorious day over at www.cronos4.tv where we will be featuring women artists all week.

This short post came to me after a reader informed me that the CBC's Michael Enright did a piece (Feb. 20) on the shortage of women with bylines at major literary publications. (Link to the show at the bottom of the page.) He interviewed Ann Hays who returned her issue of the New Yorker  because it featured so few women writers and sent a letter to the publishers. She then posted it on Facebook, where it caused a sensation! To read the letter click here.

Enright also interviewed the spokesperson for VIDA Women in the Literary Arts about its publication in February entitled "the Count," in which the number of men vs. women working at literary publications had been tallied. He then spoke with several magazine editors from the US and Canada, Mother Jones and the Walrus among them, in an attempt to get to the bottom of sexism in the publishing world.

Of course, we heard, "Oh no, no, no, not at our magazine," and their figures did sound, well skewed, but I hope after hearing this, many of you will start counting the number of bylines given to women before you buy your magazine to give those old publishers a sense of what a girlcott might feel like. 

Now if the CBC would only look into its own sexist practices, such as repeatedly giving more awards to male writers (Canada Reads 80% vs. 20% in the last 10 years) and giving equal exposure to women writers, both on the air and on its website, then we might start to see some change. Nothing like pointing the finger at magazines to divert the attention from yourselves.

Just to warn you: there are a few cackle-worthy statements in this 40-minute segment. My favourite came from the editor of the legal magazine: (not verbatim, but along these lines) Well, we have to take very difficult content and make it more palatable to the reader. In other words, they have to dumb it down and apparently only men can do this...

The other hilarious statement came from the Canadian Editor of the Walrus: (again along these lines) There are more men who are willing to do freelance work because women need more job security. Ahmm...BS detector activated!

Please tell me your favourite line.

Here's the podcast:

CBC.ca | The Sunday Edition | Women in Publishing - MMR Autism Scandal - Phil Ochs Documentary

Other posts on sexism in publishing
Guerrilla Girls, Humour and Hope
Publishing: What If...?
Publishing: What's "Good" and "Important"  (Stats on the # of books authored by women that are reviewed)
CBC: The Elephant in the Room  (Terry Fallis's book beats Carol Shields in CanadaReads)
Reads from Men


.
Read more »
2 com

Guerrilla Girls, Humour and Hope

Since 1985, the Guerrilla Girls have been raising awareness about the minimal representation of works by women and people of colour in museums. Their number one warfare tactic is humour. Donning gorilla masks and hairy hands, they have been brandishing posters and stickers, staging street theatre and demonstrating at art gatherings to bring attention to their cause. The Girls go by pseudonyms of famous women artists, such as Emily Carr and Frida Kahlo, never revealing their true identities. Their tagline: "Fighting discrimination with facts, humour and fake fur."

One of their most famous campaigns was "the Weenie Count," in which they tallied the number of male and female nudes exhibited at New York's Metropolitan Museum of Art. They discovered that only 3% of the artists in the Met's collection were women, yet women made up 87% of the museum's nudes. This gave rise to the creation of their now famous poster, which they plastered all over the streets of New York. The Guerrilla Girls eventually expanded their brand of activism to other cultural arenas, including the film industry in Hollywood. To raise awareness about discrimination in cinema, they posted headlines around Tinsel Town during Oscar season that read "The Anatomically Correct Oscar: He’s white and male, just like the guys who win!" The Guerrilla Girls even created a poster to commemorate the 20th anniversary of Montreal Massacre with the Université de Québec à Montréal.

For more examples of their work, please visit their site, which is both edifying and hilarious. Their posters and books can be purchased on their site. I just bought the Guerrilla Girls' Bedside Companion to the History of Western Art.

In 2001, some former GG members created a theatre collective, the Guerrilla Girls On Tour (check out the great downloadable posters and stickers!), while another group was formed to address Internet and workplace issues, the Guerrilla Girls Broadband. All three groups use snark and humour to raise awareness about sexism and discrimination.

I have been following the Guerrilla Girls On Tour on Twitter for about two years, and last November, I was pleased to see one of their tweets. The GGsOT announced that the New York Times had given into pressure from feminist groups and women's rights activists like the GGs and named 50 books authored by women in its 100 Notable Books of 2010. Enfin success!

This entire week I have been writing about sexism in the Canadian publishing industry. I've even suggested a girlcott. However, now I'm thinking more about the awareness that could be raised through facts and humour...Let me know what you think, and remember it's dead easy to print stickers. MaHaHa!

Other posts-related to sexism in publishing
Publishing: What If...?
Publishing: What's "Good" and "Important"  (Stats on the # of books authored by women that are reviewed)
CBC: The Elephant in the Room  (Terry Fallis's book beats Carol Shields in CanadaReads)
Reads from Men


...
Read more »
0 com

Publishing: What If...?

This week, Charles Foran became the 10th winner of the Charles Taylor Award for literary non-fiction for his book on Mordecai Richler, Mordecai, the Life & Times. Foran will also be receiving the $25,000 that goes with the award. What a coincidence and marketing coup that it won the same year as the critical success of Barney's Version, the film adaptation of the Mordecai Richler book...

The three-judge panel, made up of two men and one woman, said that it was Foran's "clear voice, conveying a unique personality and tone, that set his work apart. Add to that an incredible eye for detail and mood." More subjectivity, but that's the nature of the beast isn't it?

In the 10 years of the Charles Taylor Award has existed, eight winners have been men and two have been women, one of whom was Carol Shields.

As many of you have noticed, there has been an explosion in the number of awards being given away to the "best" and "most important." Right now the CBC has it's Bookies, which we can all go online and vote for. I guess the growing number of contests, awards, prizes and galas, is another way to hedge our bets and find "the best."  This is no criticism, as I'm short on time like everyone else and do the same thing myself.

We live in a society with an increasing amount of choice, a selection so vast that it boggles the mind. The last thing we want to do is pick a dog of a book or waste our money on a mediocre film, so we look for the winner of high profile awards, the vast majority of which, in the publishing world at least, go to men.

What if...?

I scrolled through the other four finalists in the 2011 Charles Taylor Award and stopped at the lone woman contender, Merrily Weisbord, for her book the Love Queen of Malabar, the story of Weisbord's 10-year friendship with Das Kemala, the first Indian woman to write an autobiographical cult classic about love and desire. Das Kemala has been referred to by her fans as "The First Feminist Emotional Revolutionary of our Time." Sounds compelling. In addition, Weisbord has written for television as well as four other books. I had enough evidence that this book could very well be "the best" and "the most important." I immediately went online and bought the hardcover edition. As for the winner's book, I have nothing against Mordecai Richler or the author of Life & Times. In fact, I have fond memories of reading the Apprenticeship of Duddy Kravitz in my Canadian Lit class in high school. And I might read Mordecai: Life & Times, if I found it at the library. I'm sure Foran won't mind. After all, he has $25,000 to console himself with.

I started to think about this as a form of protest against the unfair sexist practices in the publishing world. What if we paid full price for books written by women and borrowed the books authored by men from the library and friends, or picked them up used? As women make up the lion's share of avid readers, we hold the balance of power. We could have our own little girlcott until publishers felt the pinch and started to change some of their unfair practices.

I realize that this may not start tomorrow. But it may pick up some momentum when more people realize that we are living in a far from egalitarian society, particularly in the publishing and entertainment industries.


PS, On Friday, it was reported in the National Posts that the sales of the Best Laid Plans, the 2011 winner of the CBC's Canada Reads series, had increased by 695% in one week.

Publishing sexism-related posts
Publishing: What's "Good" and "Important"  (Stats on the # of books authored by women that are reviewed)
CBC: The Elephant in the Room  (Terry Fallis's book beats Carol Shields in CanadaReads)
Reads from Men


.
Read more »
4 com

Publishing: What's "Good" and "Important"?

I say this book is "the best."
In researching further information on the apparent sexism in the publishing industry, I came across some more compelling evidence that the publishing world has a definite gender bias. I also answered the question I asked last fall: Why do male authors always get so much more press than their female counterparts?

If you're like me, I usually ask people around me for book recommendations before I shell out any money. I see what's at the library, read online book reviews and look at the used bookstore. A trip to the large bookstore chains can be dangerous because I usually spend far too much money; so many things look so appealing. In other words, I'm always on the look-out for something I might like to read. Otherwise, it's a little like looking for a needle in a haystack.

Now consider this. Just this month, Vida: Women in Literary Arts published some astonishing figures about the number of women working at major literary publications, the number of reviews women wrote and the number of women's books that were reviewed. Here's just a few statistics:

At the New Yorker in 2010
Number of reviews written by women: 8
Number of reviews written by men: 29
Number of women authors reviewed: 76
Number of men authors reviewed: 158

At the Times Literary Supplement in 2010
Number of reviews written by women: 341
Number of reviews written by men: 900
Number of women authors reviewed: 330
Number of men authors reviewed: 1,036

At the New York Times Book Review in 2010
Number of reviews written by women: 295
Number of reviews written by men: 438
Number of women authors reviewed: 283
Number of men authors reviewed: 524

Source: http://vidaweb.org/the-count-2010


In other words, books authored by men are reviewed more often, and there are substantially more men reviewing books. So the people who are telling us which books are "the best" and "important" and creating the hype are in most cases those with a "Y" chromosome.

I recently spoke with an author who told me that in the publishing world, it is often said that what women write about is often not considered "important." Yes, it's true that there are people with whom I've chosen not to discuss books because I wasn't sure that we could see eye to eye on what was "important." But in the end what is "important" and "the best" are completely subjective...so maybe we should be looking for reviewers who hold similar views of what is "the best" and "important" to our own.

Other publishing-related posts:
CBC: The Elephant in the Room
Reads from Men



.
Read more »
10 com

CBC: Elephant in the Room

I've been pondering this for a few days, thinking of ways to phrase the obvious without making it look like sour grapes. No, the book that I thought should win the Canada Read 2011 series did not win this year, but deciding the best book, like the best bagel, is a completely subjective decision, which we all can't agree on, and this is something that I acknowledge.

But a few words have to be said about the obvious.

The Canada Reads 2011 series has now been running for 10 years, and its objective was to get Canadians reading, and reading Canadian authors. The series is a win-win situation for our national publishing industry and our authors who reap the benefits of increased exposure and book sales. I must admit that if it had not been for Canada Reads, I would not have read Guy Vanderhaege's the Last Crossing, Leo McKay's  Twenty-Six or Angie Abdou's the Bone Cage, three stories that I adored. The series has also demonstrated that Canada has many world class writers, and this was not the case when I was studying Canadian Lit in high school in the 1980s.

Indeed, we have come a long way. Canadians now read books by Canadians and even enjoy them. But now we need to look a little closer at the results of the last 10 years. I've done a little research and found that of the 50 finalists over the 10 years, only 19 women authors have made it into the finals (38% vs 62%), and in this past decade only two women have actually won (20% vs. 80%). There was a glimmer of hope this year when three women actually made it into the finals, one of whom was Pulitzer Prize winning novelist Carol Shields. Unless made it into the top five, Ms. Shield's final book in a stellar literary career. Initially, it hardly seemed fair that her end-of-career book would be competing against four first-time novels.

But surprise! Terry Fallis's The Best Laid Plans, the self-published book and "the Cinderella story" won the Canada Reads' essential book of the decade title. Everyone loves an underdog! Self-published authors are smiling from ear to ear across Canada. Then the other male finalist, the graphic novelist Jeff Lemire, won the CBC's People's Choice Award. Woohoo! Both men won awards.

I don't see Fallis's win as a "Cinderella story," I see it as a perfect illustration of the sexism portrayed in Shield's Unless--in other words, the elephant in the room that no one seems to be talking about. In this semi-autobiographical book, we see via Reta, our protagonist, how women's books are often ignored and undervalued. Our cautious protagonist's rage builds throughout the book, but her anger only surfaces when her editor, Mr. Springer, wants to make her book into "great fiction," which involves her assuming a pen name and changing the point of view from the female lead to that of the male protagonist. That way men would buy the book--the age old argument! Women read books written by women and men, but men only read books written by men.

Sorry, I don't buy that men only read men and that there's no way around it, particularly with all the marketing gurus out there who can sell cars, homes and just about any other consumer product to people who don't need them or have the money to buy them. This is intentional sexism, and some people obviously like the publishing industry the way it is.

The most aggravating part is that women make up the lion's share of readers. According to a UK study published in the Guardian in March 2009, 48% of women were avid readers while only 26% of men fell into this category. An avid reader was defined as someone who "cannot put a book down once they begin it and who reliably get through a long list of titles in an average year."

As a publicly funded broadcaster, the CBC should be investigating the Canadian publishing industry and getting to the bottom of some of its sexist practices. Rather than just perpetuating rampant sexism, the Corporation should be using its considerable power to influence the very industry that it helped build. In addition, it might start by giving equal exposure to women writers, looking into who is winning all the literary prizes and creating a list of best practices that publishing companies would need to follow in order to receive a CBC endorsement.

I'm sure there's a lot more our nationally owned radio and television network could do instead of just throwing its hands in the air and saying, "We didn't make the decision. It was the panel." This is a deep-seated issue that requires a little more than a glib "oh well!" response.

I'll just close with some 2009 statistics about who is winning all the literary awards and prize money in the US:

Amazon- Top 100 Editor’s Picks 2009

77 Men
23 Women

Los Angeles Times Book Prize 2009

Innovator’s Award- 1 Man
Robert Kirsch Award- 1 Man

LA Times Favorite Fiction 2009

16 Men
9 Women

The National Book Awards 2009

Fiction- 1 Man
Nonfiction- 1 Man
Poetry- 1 Man
Young People’s Literature- 1 Man

Publishers Weekly Best Books of 2009

71 Men
29 Women

Publishers Weekly Top 10 Books of 2009

10 Men
0 Women

Slate- Best Reads of 2009

15 Men
7 Women

Pulitzer Prize for Fiction 1948-2009

40 Men
16 Women

© 2010 VIDA
www.vidaweb.org
Author: Amy King
Read more »
1 com

Commodification: Rinse, Fold, Stack Him, Mr. Perfect

As many of you know, my husband works in advertising. His input often helps me take a step back from my initial interpretations and look at how the crafty advertising team is trying to get my attention and etch a visual into my memory. Apparently, the greater the emotional response the advertising vehicle or message elicits, the greater the chance the consumer will remember the product being advertised. For instance, a fast-food restaurant will use a brightly coloured clown and collectible toys as its vehicle to attract children to its restaurant.


Lately, I've noticed that commodification has become a more popular trend, or using human beings as a commodity that can be purchased, consumed and discarded. As a feminist, I feel that the advertising industry has long commodified and objectified women with impunity, but yesterday, I was surprised by my husband's reaction to men being commodified.

While running some errands in the car together, he said, "I can't wait to show you this Norwegian advertisement I saw. It was really harsh and sexist."
"Oh really," I said looking at a billboard of a topless woman on all fours pretending to be a table.
"Yes," he said, "If they treated women with this kind of violence, the feminists would be up in arms and with good reason. It was shocking."
Needless to say, I was intrigued. He later sent me the link to a 46-second public service announcement (see below) that encourages people to assist recovery efforts and recycle used packaging materials in Norway. The advertisement is entitled, "Rinse, Fold and Stack Him, Mr. Perfect."

I agree that this advertisement commodifying men as empty milk cartons, which are to be rinsed, folded and stacked before being tossed with some other "used men" under the sink, is disrespectful and tasteless, but shocking? No. Women have been commodified and objectified in advertising for as long as I can remember. Part of me wants to ask, "So how does it feel?", while another part just wants to dismiss it and say "Oh it's just advertisers trying to get people to rinse their recyclables. Nothing more, nothing less." But this would make me no better than everyone and everything I abhor in the advertising world. Bottom line: Men and women have to work together on this to get rid of all forms of sexist advertising...Am I dreaming?

Readers: How does this ad make you feel? Would you feel the same way if the woman character had been the empty milk carton? Would you call this a clever way to get people to recycle? Do you find this ad shocking?

Read more »
3 com

So Glad I'm Not 18

On a recent night out, I asked one of my friends about her 17-year-old daughter. I knew that she had just started college and was wondering how things were going. We talked about the number of life changes at that age and how difficult it was to keep priorities straight. We also talked about this being the age when people met their first love. The trials and tribulations of being 17, I was told, had led to a mother-daughter argument about time management. Mother had offered her daughter some unsolicited advice, and daughter had resented the interference. My friend told me that, mid-row, all she could think about was Alice Cooper's song, "I'm 18."

The song played in my head until the next day when I looked up the lyrics. Of course, I'd remembered the music and refrain, but, I confess, not the lyrics.

I got a baby´s brain and an old man´s heart
Took eighteen years to get this far
Don´t always know what I´m talkin´ about
Feels like I´m livin´ in the middle of doubt
Cause I´m eighteen
I get confused every day
Eighteen
I just don´t know what to say
Eighteen
I gotta get away

Was it because I was too involved with being 18 to understand, or was it because I couldn't relate to Alice Cooper, an old guy, telling me what it was like to be 18?

At any rate, I may not have remembered the lyrics, but I certainly recall how important music was to me when I was growing up. Whether it was folk, new wave or progressive rock, music was my way to discover life and the outside world while growing up in a conservative small town. I was more inclined, however, to listen to the music rather than the lyrics, and I just recently discovered why.

I thought about the general theme of love and relationships in mainstream music, as they are often on the minds of young adults, and decided to research some of the lyrics to songs about hooking up when I was a teen. I was both amused and repulsed by what I discovered.

The first song that came to mind was an old folk rock tune, which probably still plays ad nauseum on classic rock stations. This song must have turned off a lot of women in search of a monogamous relationship.

Love the One You're With (Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young)

If you're down and confused
And you don't remember who you're talkin' to
Concentration slip away
Cause your baby is so far away.
Well, there's a rose in a fisted glove
And the eagle flies with the dove
And if you can't be with the one you love
Love the one you're with
Love the one you're with

I had a good laugh at the "rose in a fisted glove." The rose, a symbol of love, but in a fisted glove. Scuse me, what's with the glove? Anyway...Correct me if you disagree, but I can't imagine a woman writing a song about a moment of weakness and it still getting airtime 40 years later. Some will say it was a time of free love...Whatever!

The other song that came to mind took me back to my early teens, and again, it received airtime for years after it was initially released in 1979-- You're All I've Got Tonight (the Cars). Here's some of it:

i don't care if you hurt me some more
i don't care if you even the score
you can knock me and i don't care
you can mock me and i don't care
you can rock me just about anywhere
it's alright
'cus you're all i've got tonight
you're all i've got tonight
you're all i've got tonight

Now, as I recall, a lot of women liked the Cars and new wave music. However, this song did not offer a very appealing picture of hooking up for either party. I'm starting to see why I remembered the music, but not the lyrics.

The next song, a progressive rock tune by the hugely popular Supertramp, was loved by everyone. Even our parents used to sing along to these songs on AM radio, but listen to the opener of the title song from Breakfast in America.

Take a look at my girlfriend
She's the only one I got
Not much of a girlfriend
I never seem to get enough

Hello! Sounds to me like love and relationships were strictly male focused, and these three songs were tame AM radio material. Wait a minute? Weren't most of the musicians and songwriters male? Yep. The record producers? Yep. The people who decided how much airtime these songs received? Yep. No wonder I couldn't remember the lyrics. I couldn't relate to the point of view.

Have things changed since then? Not according to Sharon Lamb and Lyn Mikel Brown, the authors of Packaging Girlhood:Rescuing Our Daughters from Marketers' Schemes. To counter the objectifying and degrading portrayal of women in pop music, they suggest that parents explain to their daughters that the music industry is overwhelmingly made up of men.

Point out the maleness of the world of pop music. For the most part, men own the companies and produce the artists and the CDs, control what gets airtime, and film the MTV videos. They're also overwhelmingly the ones in bands (U2, Green Day, Simple Plan, Yellowcard, Death Cab for Cutie, Maroon 5, Korn, and so on). (p.154)

Yes, there were women in pop music when I was a teen, but they were not nearly as successful or had the same longevity or amount of airtime as their male counterparts. There are, however, more women making money and enjoying success in the music industry today. The Madonnas, Christinas, Brittneys and Avrils have indeed become superstars, but how many of their equally successful male counterparts have had to sex it up, take off some clothes or go blond to maintain their market shares? Ah, none.

But this post was about lyrics wasn't it? Are there lyrics about love in mainstream music today that are written from a woman's perspective? Are these lyrics sex-positive without objectifying women? Please tell me about them. Maybe I will be able to remember them for once.

Related posts:
More Impossible Beauty Standards

What if Bill Gates Had Been Born A Poor Black Girl

Our Hypersexualized Media: How to Help Our Children

The Gold Standard of Beauty: Targetting Insecurities

Dora the Explorer: The Power of A Petition

Cookie-Cutter Plain
Read more »